Toronto Maple Leafs Captain Auston Matthews Meets Donald Trump's Today

The Setup

Trump had invited the men's team to attend his State of the Union address on Tuesday night after calling the team in their locker room immediately following the gold medal win, with FBI Director Kash Patel present in the dressing room. The women's team, who also won gold over Canada, declined Trump's invitation citing scheduling conflicts. The men, most of them, went.

TSN's Darren Dreger reported that the team was headed to a 12:30 p.m. ET luncheon on Tuesday before the evening address. Matthews, specifically, was confirmed by Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube to be expected in the lineup against the Tampa Bay Lightning on Wednesday — meaning the Leafs captain's Tuesday looked like this: White House luncheon, State of the Union address as a special guest of the President of the United States, then get on a plane back to Canada to play an NHL game tomorrow night.

Five players on Team USA declined the White House invitation.

The Matthews Predicament

Auston Matthews was born in Scottsdale, Arizona. He is American. He captained Team USA with distinction: tallying three goals and four assists in six games, including an assist on the USA's first goal against Canada in the final. He carried himself with professionalism throughout the tournament and did the right things at the right moments. None of that is in dispute.

He is also the captain of the Toronto Maple Leafs, the most scrutinized franchise in Canadian professional sports, playing in a city where the Olympic gold medal loss hit hard. The Leafs dressing room itself was divided, Matthew Knies and Morgan Rielly were among the players whose reactions reflected that split, with Americans on the team smiling ear-to-ear and Canadians processing a loss. William Nylander, who Canada eliminated in the quarterfinals, said flatly: "I'm super happy for him. But I'm obviously upset that we lost."¹

Matthews navigated all of it carefully. When asked about the Trump invitation immediately after the gold medal game, he was measured: "For us, it's a huge moment for the United States. He called and just congratulated us. I think there's a lot of moving parts as far as our travels back home. We'll kind of see what happens, but obviously it's an [honour] to wear this jersey and to represent the U.S."²

That is, for Matthews, a completely normal answer. He has spent his entire NHL career threading exactly this kind of needle, an American in Canada's hockey capital, beloved for what he does on the ice, careful to the point of opacity about anything off it. When asked previously about anthem protests and U.S.-Canada political tensions, his answer was four words: "I'm not going to get into politics."³

What It Means for the Leafs

Practically speaking, very little. Matthews is expected to play Wednesday. The White House visit is a one-day story. He will return to Toronto, take his spot on the top line, and the Leafs' season — currently sitting at 10% playoff odds and trending toward an off-season reckoning — will resume. The fans in Toronto who bought his jersey and cheered for him all season are not going to stop doing either because he went to Washington for a day.

But there is a version of this that the Leafs faithful are sitting with quietly, and it's not about politics. It's about the image of the man wearing the C — the captain of their team — celebrating in the Oval Office after scoring a point against Canada in an Olympic final, while the country that employs him, pays to watch him, and gave him a captaincy he's never come close to winning a championship with is still feeling the sting of Sunday morning.

Matthews didn't do anything wrong. He represented his country. He went to his country's White House. He is an American.

He is also the captain of the Toronto Maple Leafs, and he was standing in the Oval Office this afternoon while Canada's most storied franchise sat at 10 percent playoff odds.

‌

‌

‌